exceptional privately owned single family home


Home Description

"Casa Dorado" is an exceptional privately owned single family home located directly on Florida Bay on Lower Matecumbe Key in Islamorada. The house is named after the owners' favorite species of fish, the Dolphinfish, also known as Dorado in Spanish speaking coastal areas. With the green roof and yellow stucco exterior, they felt like Casa Dorado was a fitting name for this Florida Keys home.

In 2014 when the current owners purchased this property they completely renovated the 1966 house turning it into a breathtaking waterfront home with quality furnishings and timeless decor. Inside, this home now offers spacious living and dining areas, three master suites each with king beds and en-suite baths and two sitting areas - one with a queen sleeper sofa. Taking advantage of the setting they greatly enhanced the water views from the interior living areas. This home offers unobstructed water views! People come from all over the world to experience the incredibly gorgeous sunsets over Florida Bay. You will be able to personally experience them directly from this property. Outside, they added a custom heated freeform pool and outdoor entertainment area. The dock area and fish cleaning station have also been updated. You must provide the fish…but you may be able to catch something delicious to eat directly from the fishing pier.

The interior décor is reminiscent of a Cape Cod beach cottage with white tongue and groove wood paneling and a nautical theme with tropical colors throughout. You will find the décor not only pleasing to the eye but very comfortable and functional. The kitchen has all new custom cabinets, granite counters, updated stainless steel appliances, including a wine chiller and a custom designed built-in casual dining area. Formal dining is located in the converted screened balcony which is now an amazing sunroom overlooking the waterfront. A spacious sitting room located in the front of the home just off the kitchen offers a lovely area for the family to gather and watch TV or review the day's events and plan tomorrows. The "L" shaped sectional sofa and two chairs provide plenty of seating. Built in cabinets and a large flat screen TV adds to the charm and functionality of this area.

If you cannot stay for a full month, we may be able to help you. Local restrictions prohibit us from renting this property more than once in a 28 day period. The owner may be willing to rent this home for less than a full month and block the remaining days. Give us a call for details.

This property is professionally managed by Keys Holiday Rentals.

About The Area


Property Located at MM 76.2 Bay Side  
Convenient to Marathon and Miami  
John Pennekamp Coral Reef State Park   MM 102.5 
Dolphin Cover MM 101.9
Jacobs Aquatic Center MM 100
Wild Bird Center MM 93.6
Harry Harris Park MM 92.5  
Rain Barrel Artists Village MM 86
Founder's Park MM 87 with community pool, white sand beach, picnic areas, skateboard park, basketball court, driving range, and amphitheater
Theater of the Sea (Dolphin, Sea Lion Shows - Swim with the Dolphin Programs) MM 84.5
Postcard Inn (formerly Holiday Isle Beach Resort & Tiki Bar) MM 84 
History of Diving Museum MM 82.9
Cheeca Lodge MM 81.8
World Wide Sportsman, Shopping, Morada Bay and Pierre’s Restaurants MM 81
Robbie's Marina-Feed the Tarpon MM 77.5
Islamorada Tennis Club   MM 76.8 
Anne’s Beach MM 73 (Oceanside)
Long Key State Recreation Area MM 67.5 
Dolphin Research Center MM 58 
Key Colony Beach Golf & Tennis MM 53.5 
Snorkeling and Scuba Diving
Windsurfing, Waterskiing, Wakeboarding
Kayaking, Canoeing
Sailing, Parasailing
Park tours
Kite boarding and paddle boarding
Bird watching
Charter Boats for Deep Sea or Backcountry Fishing
Bike Trails
Movie Theaters
Gourmet or Casual Dining
Fabulous Waterfront Restaurants
Fishing – Deep Sea or Back Country
Fishing Party Boats 
Private Captains and Boats for Charter
Boat Rentals
Fitness Centers


Room Details

Sleeping Arrangements

  • Master Suite 1 King

  • King Bedroom on Bayside 1 King

  • King Bedroom on Street Side 1 King

  • Den 1 Sofa Bed

Bathroom Arrangements

  • Master Ensuite BathroomFull

  • Hallway BathroomHalf

  • Guest Jack-N-Jill BathroomFull

  • 2nd Guest BathroomFull

Calendar Last updated Jul 30, 2018
  • Open
  • Not Available




Beautiful Home

Beautiful home with great access to boat launch and dockage at the house. Very neat and clean and every amenity you could want. Had some AC problems that Keys Holiday Rentals handled quickly and professionally. My family will return. By the way, the fishing from the seawall at the house was great. This was our second stay at Casa Dorado.

Visited on "May - 2017

Contact the Manager
My travel dates are flexible.
By clicking 'Send Email' you are agreeing to our Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Owner Profile